By Shingirai Vambe
Fresh Labour Court setback leaves the cash-strapped local authority facing mounting employment liabilities, questions over its leadership and a prolonged vacancy in the engineering department.
Rusape Town Council’s seemingly endless legal battles have become an expensive institutional embarrassment, with the latest Labour Court judgment exposing the extent to which the local authority has pursued litigation against its own town engineer, Engineer Charles Chindenga, despite repeated setbacks in the courts.
What began as a disciplinary dispute has developed into a prolonged legal confrontation that has consumed time, public resources and administrative attention, while raising uncomfortable questions about whether Council’s determination to keep Chindenga out of office has been driven by legitimate institutional concerns or a bitter internal power struggle.
The latest ruling, delivered by Justice Gonesi on October 26, 2026, has dealt another blow to the local authority after the Labour Court dismissed Council’s application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against an earlier judgment upholding Chindenga’s reinstatement.
The decision leaves Council facing the consequences of a dispute that has dragged on for months, with the engineer’s employment benefits and back pay accumulating while the municipality continues to grapple with financial constraints and service-delivery demands.
The already struggling small farming town with deteriorating roads, water challenges, sewage problems and other municipal pressures, having this dispute represents more than an employment disagreement. It raises questions about leadership priorities, institutional accountability and the cost to residents of allowing internal administrative conflicts to become prolonged courtroom battles.
Chindenga was charged and suspended by Council pending disciplinary proceedings. However, the disciplinary authority found him not guilty and ordered his reinstatement without loss of salary and benefits.
Council was dissatisfied with the outcome and appealed to the Labour Court. That appeal was dismissed for lack of merit, but the local authority persisted, seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.

Its initial application was struck off the roll in June 2026 after an incompetent relief had been sought. Council subsequently returned to the Labour Court with a composite application seeking condonation for the late filing of its application and permission to appeal.
In its latest judgment, the court acknowledged that Council had provided an explanation for the delay and granted condonation. However, that procedural relief did not translate into permission to pursue the substantive appeal.
Justice Gonesi dismissed the application for leave to appeal, finding that Council had failed to demonstrate reasonable prospects of success.
Council argued that the disciplinary authority had recognised that relations between the parties had deteriorated and that it was therefore irrational to order the engineer’s reinstatement.
Its lawyer, M. Majojo, argued that the authorities could not conclude that the relationship had broken down while simultaneously compelling the parties to continue working together.
But the court rejected the argument, relying on established legal principles distinguishing between an employee who has been dismissed and one who has merely been suspended.
Justice Gonesi cited the Supreme Court judgment in Cimas Medical Aid Society v Tapiwa Nyandoro, which clarified that where an employee is suspended but subsequently acquitted, reinstatement ordinarily means lifting the suspension and restoring the employee to the position held before it, with no loss of salary and benefits.
The judge found that Chindenga had not been dismissed and that his acquittal meant the employment relationship remained intact.
The court therefore saw no legal basis for Council’s argument that it should be allowed to substitute reinstatement with damages.
Perhaps the most damaging part of the judgment for Council concerns the allegations of neglect relating to drainage systems at Mabvazuva Main Trunk Sewer and BC Housing Scheme.
Council accused Chindenga of failing to attend to the drainage problems, which allegedly resulted in flooding and created a serious public health risk.
However, Chindenga’s defence was that he had made the necessary requisitions for resources, but the requests had not been processed or funded through the procurement system.
Council disputed that explanation, arguing that the engineer had failed to produce documents supporting his claims and that the Labour Court had effectively reversed the burden of proof.
Justice Gonesi was not persuaded.
The court found that Council, as the employer and custodian of the relevant records, had failed to demonstrate that the necessary resources had been made available to Chindenga.
It further noted that Council had not shown that the requisitions were provided but that the engineer subsequently failed to act.
The judge upheld the finding that the disciplinary authority had been justified in acquitting him.
Meanwhile, Rusape has spent close to a year operating without a qualified town engineer in the position, according to the circumstances surrounding the dispute.
That absence raises serious concerns for a local authority whose responsibilities include roads, drainage, sewer infrastructure, water systems, development control and other technical services, when residents continue to complain about poor roads, sewage problems, unreliable water supplies and deteriorating infrastructure, the absence of a substantive engineering head represents an administrative weakness that cannot be separated from the town’s service-delivery challenges.
Council may have its internal reasons for resisting Chindenga’s return, but the continued dispute has left the municipality exposed to an uncomfortable question of how much public money and institutional energy has been spent fighting an employment case while critical municipal services remain under pressure?
The costs are not limited to legal fees. There are potential salary and benefit liabilities, management time, administrative disruption and the opportunity cost of failing to resolve the dispute.
Chindenga’s entitlement to salary and benefits during the period in question is grounded in the disciplinary authority’s reinstatement order, which was upheld by the Labour Court. The latest judgment reinforces that position by rejecting Council’s attempt to obtain leave to appeal.
The precise amount outstanding, however, would need to be established from Council’s payroll records and the applicable employment calculations.

The latest ruling dismisses the Labour Court application for leave to appeal. However, it would be premature to declare that every possible legal avenue has been exhausted, as section 92F(3) of the Labour Court Act provides for an approach to a Supreme Court judge where leave has been refused by the Labour Court.
The courts have repeatedly directed the parties towards the legal consequences of Chindenga’s acquittal. The latest judgment has made Council’s position even more difficult to sustain, with the Town Secretary, Solomon Gabaza allegedly and indirectly pushing for those who stood in his position and against him when he was suspended and fired from Rusape Town Council for criminal abuse of office.
His return and illegal reinstatement to council on full benefits without being tried and standing for the raised allegations remain a test of time for the Zimbabwe Republic Police (ZRP) Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission (ZACC), National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and the Government of Zimbabwe fighting the ever spreading cancer of corruption in Zimbabwe.

More Stories
Applicant Fires Salvo, Then Fails to Show Up
Garwe’s Demolition Drive, ZANU PF Risks Losing The Votes Of The Victims
CAA3 Puts Judicial Independence To The Test